Our Menu

Delicious, fresh, and made to order.

Traditional Cheese Pizza

Build your own masterpiece

Classic Sizes

  • 14" Traditional Cheese19.99
  • 18" Traditional Cheese29.99
  • XL Traditional Cheese38.99
  • Paul's Sicilian Crust34.99

*Add $5 to your favorite 18" specialty pizza price for Sicilian

Specialty Crusts

Note: For Dine-In Orders Only!!
  • 10" Gluten-Free Cauliflower12.49
  • 12" Gluten-Free Crust13.49
  • California Crust (12")17.99

Toppings & Prices

Topping Pricing
  • 10"$1.00 - $2.50
  • 12" & CA$1.50 - $3.50
  • 14"$2.00 - $4.00
  • 18"$3.00 - $5.00
  • XL$3.50 - $5.50
  • Sicilian$3.00 - $5.00
Available Toppings

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Garlic, Roasted Garlic, Tomato, Pesto, Black Olive, Ham, Pineapple, Salami, Mushroom, Broccoli, Bacon, Provolone, Meatball, Yellow Onion, Red Onion, Sauteed Spinach, Fresh Spinach, Jalapeno, Sun-Dried Tomato, Artichoke Hearts, Basil, Pepperoncini, Garlic Butter, Red Bell Peppers, Green Bell Peppers, Extra-Mozzarella, Cheddar, Bleu Cheese Crumble, Feta, Ricotta, Chicken, Anchovy, Pulled Pork, & Seasonal Items.

Double Crusted Specialty Pizzas

The Brooklyn

Double crusted pie filled with sautéed spinach, garlic, ricotta & mozzarella.

14": $23.99 | 18": $38.99 | XL: $49.99

The Hitman

Double crusted with sauce, pepperoni, salami, bacon, sausage & mozzarella.

14": $23.99 | 18": $38.99 | XL: $49.99

Paul's Specialty Pizzas

Available in 10in GF, 12in GF, 14in, 18in, and XL sizes

The Sunset

Traditional pizza with sun-dried tomato, pineapple & basil

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

Margherita

Mozzarella base with fresh & roasted garlic, seasoned mozzarella, pizza sauce & basil

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The Vegetarian

Traditional pizza with tomato, yellow onion, garlic & broccoli

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

Olive Special

Traditional pizza with artichoke, black olives, garlic & basil

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The Joe Namath

A pesto base, with mozzarella, tomato, garlic, & basil

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

La Bruschetta

Tomato & garlic base, sharp provolone, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato pesto & basil

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

Garden of Eden

Fresh spinach, fresh tomato, mozzarella, pizza sauce, ricotta dollops & topped with feta

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

The Godfather

Ricotta base with a hint of garlic, mozzarella, fresh tomato, sun-dried tomatoes & pesto

10" GF 15.49 | 12" GF 16.99 | 14" 23.99 | 18" 38.99 | XL 49.99

The Greek

Pesto & fresh spinach base, mozzarella, olives, sun-dried tomato, red onions and feta

10" GF 15.49 | 12" GF 16.99 | 14" 23.99 | 18" 38.99 | XL 49.99

Rumble in D'bronx

Traditional cheese pizza with pineapple, bacon & jalapeno

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

Buffalo Chicken

Ranch sauce base, red onion, seasoned chicken, mozzarella, & buffalo sauce!!

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

New Amsterdam

Traditional pizza with mushroom, sausage, yellow onions, & pepperoni

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The BBQ Pizza

Traditional cheese pizza with chicken, bacon & red onion, then BBQ sauce on top

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

Off-Broadway

Traditional pizza with mushroom, sausage, green bell pepper & yellow onion

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The 'Roni Special

Traditional cheese pizza with pepperoni, basil, tomato & garlic

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The Wise Guy

Traditional pizza with sausage, green peppers, yellow onions & garlic

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The Hawaii 5-0

A traditional ham and pineapple pizza with bacon & BBQ sauce added

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

The B.L.T

A ranch based pizza with fresh spinach, bacon, tomato & mozzarella

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

4 Meat Special

Traditional pizza with pepperoni, sausage, salami & bacon

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

Tony Soprano

Traditional pizza with mushroom, sausage, red onion & ricotta

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

The Guido

Traditional pizza with sausage, green peppers, red peppers, red onion & pepperoncini

10" GF 13.49 | 12" GF 14.99 | 14" 21.99 | 18" 36.99 | XL 47.99

Chicken Club

A ranch sauce base, mozzarella, tomato, red onion, chicken & bacon

10" GF 14.99 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

Florentine

Fresh spinach, chicken, roasted garlic, provolone, & garlic butter under mozzarella

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

Pesto Paradise

A pesto based pizza with fresh spinach, mushroom, bacon, red onion & mozzarella

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

Manhattan

Pesto base pizza with fresh tomatoes, sundried tomatoes, artichoke hearts & chicken topped with mozzarella

10" GF 14.49 | 12" GF 15.99 | 14" 22.99 | 18" 37.99 | XL 48.99

New York Combo

Traditional pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, salami, green bell pepper, black olives & yellow onion

10" GF 15.49 | 12" GF 16.99 | 14" 23.99 | 18" 38.99 | XL 49.99

Pizza Rolls

*Additional items $1 - $2

Sausage Roll

$12.49

Italian sausage, green bell pepper, yellow onion, red sauce & mozzarella wrapped in dough.

Veggie Roll

$12.49

Mushroom, green bell pepper, black olives, yellow onion, red sauce & mozzarella wrapped in dough.

Calzones

A pocket of dough stuffed generously with ricotta and mozzarella cheese. Marinara on the side!

Mini-Vinnie Calzone

$10.49

Large Calzone

$18.49

Salads

Served with a dinner bread

Dinner Salad

Spring mix, red onion, grape tomato, romano & croutons

Sm $7.99 | Lg $9.49

Garden Salad

$14.49

Spring mix, artichoke, black olives, mushroom, provolone, jalapeños, tomato & romano

Antipasto Salad

$16.99

Spring mix, artichoke, olives, mushroom, provolone, salami, pepperoni, sun-dried tomato & romano

Caesar Salad

$13.99

Romaine, caesar dressing, tomato, provolone, croutons & romano

+ Bacon $2.99 | + Chicken $3.99 | + Breaded Chicken $5.49

Buffalo Salad

$16.99

Spring mix, bleu cheese, red onion, four buffalo chicken tenders

Entrees & Pasta

Includes Small Dinner Salad, Garlic Bread, or Dinner Breads

Beef Lasagna

$18.99

Seasoned beef, ricotta, marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano.

Spinach Lasagna

$18.49

Sautéed spinach, ricotta, marinara, mozzarella.

Chicken Parmigiana

$18.49

Breaded chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella on spaghetti.

Eggplant Parmigiana (Seasonal)

$18.49

Breaded eggplant, marinara, mozzarella on spaghetti.

Baked Ziti

$17.49

Creamy marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano.

+2 Meatballs $4 | +3 Meatballs $5

Deep-Fried Ravioli

$17.49

Eight cheese ravioli in marinara.

Spaghetti Marinara

$15.49

+2 Meatballs $4 | +3 Meatballs $5

Hot Sandwiches

Served with French fries. Sub salad available with upcharge.

Meatball Hero

$15.99

Homemade meatballs, marinara, mozzarella, parsley & romano.

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

$15.99

Breaded chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella.

Italian Sausage, Pepper & Onion Hero

$15.99

Sausage, bell peppers, onions, marinara, mozzarella.

Chicken Dijon Hero

$13.99

Breaded chicken breast, mozzarella, tomato, onion, dijon ranch.

Breads

Garlic Bread (2)

$4.99

+ Cheese $0.50

Dinner Breads (3)

$2.22

Garlic Knots (7)

$5.99

Appetizers

Mussels Marinara

$14.49

Hot & Spicy or Mild

Deep Fried Ravioli (8)

$8.99

French Fries

$5.99

Sautéed Broccoli

$6.99

Wings & Tenders

Chicken Wings (12)

$14.99

Buffalo, BBQ, Thai, or Plain

Chicken Tenders (4)

$8.99

On The Side

3 Meatballs in Marinara

$8.88

With romano & parsley

Pizza Sauce or Homemade Marinara

Varies

Both available in two sizes

Salad Dressing (2oz.)

$0.66

Any of 5 varieties

Dessert

Famous New York Cannoli

$7.99

Pastry shell stuffed with sweet ricotta & chocolate chips