Pages Navigation Menu

#1 Pizza in Arcata Eureka Humboldt Pauls Live From New York

Sandwiches & More


Mussels Marinara


Order Hot & Spicy or Mild

Buffalo Wings

Half Order - $7.99

Full Order - $11.99

Available in Buffalo Sauce, BBQ, Thai, or Plain



Sauteed Broccoli W/ Garlic


French Fries


Mozzarella Sticks

(6) - $8.99

Garlic Bread


With Cheese- $5.49

Garlic Knots served with Marinara

(5) - $3.99

Soup of The Day (served with Dinner Bread)

Creamy Tomato Basil  or Clam Chowder $6.99

Soup & Fries


Soup & Small Dinner Salad




Side Orders

Two Meatballs


Three Meatballs


Marinara Sauce

Small (2 oz) - $.59

Large (16 oz) - $4.99

Pizza Sauce


Pizza Dough

Large (18"pie)  - $8.99

Medium (14" pie) - $4.99 



any 5 varieties



Antipasta Salad 

A Lettuce Mix With Artichoke Hearts, Black Olives, Salami, Pepperoni, Aged Provolone, Sun-Dried Tomatoes, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Red Onions & Topped with Grated Romano

Small $10.99 

Large $ 12.99

Cesar Salad - $9.99

Romaine lettuce tossed with caesar dressing, tomato, provolone, croutons & romano

With Chicken $11.99

Garden Salad 

Our Spring Lettuce Mix, Cucumbers, Artichoke Hearts, Sliced Olives, Mushrooms & Aged Provolne with Fresh Tomatoes, Romano and Sliced JalapeƱos

Small - $8.99

Large - $10.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad or BBQ Salad

Spring Mix Topped With Spicy or BBQ Pieces of Chicken, Blue Cheese Crumbles & Red Onions 


Dinner Salad 

Our Spring Lettuce Mix topped with Fresh Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Red Onions, Croutons

Small - $5.99

Large - $6.99


Vegan Salad 

A Garden Salad without provolone or romano or dinner bread

Small $7.99

Large $9.99


Meatball Hero


Home-made Meatballs  covered in marinara, mozzarella & romano

Chicken Parmigiana Hero


Breaded Chicken tenders baked with marinara, mozzarella & romano

Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions

Sausage, green bell peppers & yellow onions with marinara, mozzarella & romano



Buffalo Chicken Wrap


Chicken tenders tossed in our buffalo wing sauce, spring mix and our bleu cheese crumbles and dressing in a flour wrap served with French fries 

BBQ Chicken Wrap


Chicken tenders tossed in our BBQ sauce, spring mix and our bleu cheese crumbles and dressing in a flour wrap served with French fries 



All Dine-in Dinners Include  Small Dinner Salad and Bread

Chicken Breast Parmigiana

Breaded chicken baked with marinara, mozzarella & romano served on spaghetti marinara

with Spaghetti


Beef Lasagna

Lightly seasoned ground beef, ricotta, marinara, mozzarella & romano layered between lasagna noodles


Cheese Ravioli

Eight large ravioli served in marinara & romano


Spaghetti With 2 Meatballs

Spaghetti marinara served with two meatballs


Spaghetti Marinara

Spaghetti served in our homemade marinara & romano


Baked Ziti Parmigiana

Ziti noodles baked in a creamy marinara sauce with mozzarella & romano




Pizza Rolls

Veggie Roll


Red Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella, Sliced Black Olives, Roasted Bell Peppers, Yellow Onions & Mushrooms 

Sausage Roll


Red Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Green Bell Peppers & Sliced Onions wrapped in pizza dough.



Happy Hour 2-5pm Daily

10 beers on Tap

Pint - $3.99

Pitcher - $10.99



House Red or White

Per Glass - $4.99


Cheese Calzone


Ricotta and Mozzarella baked inside. Served With Marinara on The Side

Mini-Vinnie Calzone


Additional Items

$.35 each to $1.50






Our Famous Cannoli

The desser of the upper crust!