Pages Navigation Menu

#1 Pizza in Arcata Eureka Humboldt Pauls Live From New York

Welcome to Paul's Live From New York Pizza


Featured Pizza Restaurant in Food Network's "Diners, Drive-ins, & Dives"

  • Live From New York Pizza Eureka
  • The Guido Red Sauce Base With Sausage, Green Peppers, Red Bell Peppers, Pepperincini & Red Onions
  • King Kong Ham, Sausage, Salami, Pepperoni, Bacon & Meatballs
  • Featured in Food Network's "Diners, Drive-ins, & Dives"
  • The Manhattan Pesto Base, Fresh Tomatoes, Sun-Dried Tomatoes, Artichoke Hearts & Chicken Topped with Mozzarella



Sun 12:00pm-9pm

Mon-Thur 11:30am-9pm

Fri-Sat 11:30am-10pm


Delivery After 5pm Every Day!

7 Days A Week



604 F St, Eureka, CA

(707) 442-5800


665 Samoa Blvd, Arcata

(707) 822-6199

Authentic New York Style Pizza!

“Hands down the best pizza in Humboldt County and I would give more stars if I could, thank you!” -Yelp Reviewer

We are committed to using the highest quality and most fresh ingredients in our Home Made Hand Tossed New York Style Thin Crust Pizza, Sandwiches, Salads, Wraps and Italian Dinners cooked in our Brick Oven! Our staff is professional, friendly and is ready to serve you!  


Come into one of our two Humboldt County locations and treat your self to a slice or two of the best thin crust pizza in the north coast!


View our menu online. Call to order a pizza delivery or drop by for carryout. Call Paul's Live From New York today in Arcata or Eureka & order a specialty pizza today!


What our customer's are saying

Good grub suprisingly. It reminded me of Italy pizza by Vatican City. The crust is nice and crunchy yet there is plenty of pepperon fat in a good way. The atmosphere isn't bad either. I am a repeat customer. I give the boys a good smack on the ass during football season. I'm not gay at all but I am pretty sure these boys run extra their tank.
Roger Rohl
Roger Rohl
08:26 26 Sep 18
Sometimes the service can be a little lackluster, but these guys make a mean pizza. The Godfather is my favorite. I haven't had a bad slice here.
Kellen Wallis
Kellen Wallis
03:48 30 Aug 18
It's good but it's a hit an miss on if they will burn the bottom or not. Ranted and raved to my daughter, she came to town, I took her to Paul's and they burned it. She went on FB and bombed it, I was sad because I like it. Oh well, I still go
cora lee
cora lee
00:59 30 Aug 18
We wanted lasagna and did a google search for it. The search brought up this restaurant and just to be sure that they had it, checked their website menu which listed a lot of pasta and other options that the restaurant actually didn't have. The guy said the website hadn't been updated for a while and that there was a second out of date menu that was floating around somewhere. My second choice was a sandwich that the also no longer had so we ordered a meats pizza. I always wanted to try a New York style pizza and since I haven't ever had a NY pizza I can't compare it to anything except a cardboard pizza. I'm not saying it's bad, I like cardboard pizza. It tasted better than one and had yummy stringy cheese, large slices of pepperoni and Canadian bacon but the crust was crunchy like one. I might have given the food a 4 star and it seemed clean except for the fingerprints on the TV’s which were probably from kids but the atmosphere was friendly and different from most any pizza place I've been to. The TV at each booth is a cool idea and I am only disappointed in the menu options which is why they get 3 stars. Please update your website menu so it doesn't trick others to come for something you can't get.
Trisha Howell
Trisha Howell
01:56 18 Jun 18
Walked in here after attempting to go to 3 other restaurants that were all closed on a Saturday night. There was a line out the door and the smell of NY style pizza wafted in the air. Plenty of seating, large portions, pizza by the piece or size, and friendly staff. This joint is buzzing.I decided to try the cheese ravioli. Seriously. I was craving pasta. The sauce was heavy on 🍅 flavor. I could have used some more spice here. However, the ravioli was delicious and salad fresh. I would definitely go back if I am ever driving through town again.
Jeff Downing
Jeff Downing
03:55 06 May 18
First off this joint should have no less than 5 stars! The food is epically great! The service is as expected from a pizza by the slice restaurant. I bought three slices because I'm visiting on business and ate every bit of the pizza, that says a lot because the slices are gigantic! Quality ingredients make for a great quality product and the proof is in the pie! If I lived here I might gain a few hundred pounds! Thanks for a bit of the east coast in an unexpected town! Next time I'm here I'll absolutely come again! Heck I may go everyday that I'm here!
Sean McKee
Sean McKee
02:03 09 Apr 18